Aluminum Carports vs Garages Which Option Offers Better Value for Homeowners

Many homeowners face a common dilemma when deciding how to protect their vehicles and add value to their property: should they invest in a traditional garage or opt for an aluminum carport? While garages provide fully enclosed storage, they often come with higher costs and longer construction times. Aluminum carports offer a compelling alternative that balances affordability, durability, and ease of installation.

Modern aluminum carport attached to a suburban home

Cost and Maintenance Differences

One of the biggest factors homeowners consider is the initial and ongoing cost. Building a garage typically requires a concrete foundation, framing, roofing, doors, and electrical work. This can easily run into tens of thousands of dollars depending on size and features. Maintenance also adds up over time, with painting, repairs, and potential issues like moisture buildup.

In contrast, aluminum carports are much more affordable to build. They usually require minimal foundation work and come with pre-engineered kits that simplify installation. Aluminum resists rust and corrosion, which means it needs less upkeep compared to wood or steel garages. This resistance is especially valuable in humid or coastal areas where moisture damage is common.

Customization and Certification

Aluminum carports can be customized to meet specific needs. For example, adding insulation helps regulate temperature, making the space more comfortable and protecting vehicles from extreme heat or cold. Some aluminum carports also come with Florida certification, ensuring they meet strict building codes for wind resistance and safety in hurricane-prone areas.

Garages offer full enclosure, which can be important for security and storage of other items beyond vehicles. However, the flexibility of aluminum carports allows homeowners to tailor their structure without the complexity and cost of a full garage.

Installation Speed and Convenience

Time is another important consideration. Constructing a garage can take weeks or even months, depending on weather, permits, and contractor schedules. Aluminum carports, on the other hand, can often be installed in just a few days. This quick turnaround means homeowners can start using their new space sooner and avoid prolonged disruption.

Impact on Home Value

Adding a garage has long been seen as a way to increase a home's resale value. However, recent data shows that improvements focused on curb appeal, including carports, also offer strong returns on investment. Aluminum carports provide a visible upgrade that protects vehicles and enhances the property’s appearance without the high price tag.

For example, a study of home improvement ROI in 2025 found that carports and garages both rank among the top projects for increasing resale value. The lower cost and maintenance of aluminum carports make them a smart choice for homeowners looking to maximize value without overspending.

Choosing between an aluminum carport and a garage depends on your budget, needs, and priorities. If you want a cost-effective, durable, and quick-to-install option that still adds significant value, aluminum carports stand out as a strong contender. They offer protection from the elements, resist rust, and can be customized to fit your climate and style.